TL;DR
Get home appliances delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
A Minnesota homeowner found that his 21-year-old water heater had rusted out and flooded much of his basement. His supply valve would not shut off, so he turned off the house’s main water; plumbers said he should also have cut power or gas before handling the heater.
A 21-year-old water heater rusted through and flooded much of a Minnesota homeowner’s basement, according to a Family Handyman report, while a faulty supply valve kept water flowing as he tried to drain the tank. Plumbers consulted by the publication said the homeowner was right to shut off the house’s main water, but should have disconnected the heater’s gas or electricity before handling it.
The homeowner, identified as Ethan, discovered the leak after filling a bathtub for his young daughter and finding the water was not hot. He opened the utility closet and found water covering most of the floor. Recognizing that the tank had rusted out, he closed its supply valve and attached a hose to the drain at the bottom of the heater.
When water was still draining after he returned from a trip to the home improvement store, Ethan realized the valve had not stopped the supply. He shut off the home’s main water instead. The next morning, he installed a replacement heater and got help from his father-in-law to carry the old unit upstairs. Ethan said it weighed more than 120 pounds and leaked during the move despite efforts to contain the water.
Plumbers told Family Handyman that gas and propane water heaters commonly last about 10 to 15 years before corrosion becomes a problem. Ethan’s tank was 21 years old. The report says cold-climate conditions may have contributed to wear, while a plumber said buildup or deteriorated gaskets can prevent an older valve from sealing. The article does not establish the precise cause of the tank failure.
A Leak Can Outrun a Shutoff
The incident shows how a failed valve can complicate an otherwise clear response to a leak. Plumber Brendan Tonks told the publication that closing the main supply was the right move once the heater’s valve failed, and warned that delaying even 10 minutes can leave hundreds of gallons on the floor. The report does not say how much water escaped in Ethan’s home.
The costs can extend beyond replacing the appliance. Family Handyman estimated a full replacement at about $700 for a DIY job and $1,500 to $3,500 with a professional. It said resulting water damage and mold remediation can reach thousands or tens of thousands of dollars if a leak is not caught and addressed promptly. Those are general estimates from the article, not a bill for Ethan’s incident.
An Aging Tank and Valve
The report describes Ethan as a confident DIYer who replaced the heater the morning after finding the leak. It says routine replacement of an internal anode rod, which helps limit corrosion, may extend a water heater’s life. The article puts the part at $20 to $50 for DIY replacement, or $150 to $600 with a professional; it gives similar costs for replacing a valve.
Age can affect the rest of a home’s plumbing, too. Ethan lives in a 1940s bungalow, and plumber Kolby Barnes told the publication that older homes may have gate valves for the main water shutoff. Barnes said those valves can also fail to close because of buildup. The report does not say whether Ethan’s main valve had that problem.
““If there’s a silver lining here, it’s that we were home when this happened.””
— Ethan, the homeowner, as quoted by Family Handyman
The Damage and Cause Are Unspecified
The report does not state the exact date of the incident, how much water entered the basement, or the final cost of cleanup and repairs. It also does not identify a confirmed cause for the tank’s corrosion beyond its age; cold conditions are presented as a possible contributing factor. No independent inspection findings or detailed account of damage to the home are provided.
The publication’s plumbers described possible reasons the supply valve did not close, including worn gaskets or buildup, but the report does not say which applied to Ethan’s valve. It also does not confirm whether the home had a leak detector or automatic shutoff system.
Inspect and Replace Aging Parts
Family Handyman’s practical guidance is to monitor an aging heater and consider maintenance before a leak occurs, including checking the anode rod and shutoff valves. The article also recommends considering a smart leak monitor that can alert homeowners or shut off water during a leak. It does not report a scheduled follow-up or further repair work at Ethan’s home.
For an active leak, the article advises turning off the water supply and shutting off the heater’s gas or electricity before working around it. Because replacement involves gas or electrical connections and can create safety hazards if handled incorrectly, Tonks recommended calling a professional. Homeowners should follow the appliance instructions and applicable local requirements, and use a licensed professional for work they are not qualified to perform.
Key Questions
Why did Ethan’s water heater fail?
The tank had rusted through after 21 years. Plumbers cited by Family Handyman said gas and propane heaters often last about 10 to 15 years, but the report does not confirm a specific cause beyond the tank’s age.
Why did water keep flowing after he closed the heater valve?
The supply valve was not closing. A plumber told the publication that worn gaskets or buildup can cause this problem on older heaters; the report does not identify which issue affected Ethan’s valve.
What should someone do if a heater is leaking?
Family Handyman advises shutting off the home’s main water if the heater’s valve fails, and cutting power or gas to the heater before handling it. Gas and electrical work can be hazardous, so contact a licensed professional if you are unsure how to proceed.
How much can a water heater replacement cost?
The article estimates about $700 for a DIY replacement and $1,500 to $3,500 for professional installation. These are general figures from the report, not Ethan’s confirmed costs.
Source: rss
NFL season / tailgating Picks
team gear
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
